Reply: Tzolk'in: The Mayan Calendar:: Reviews:: Re: First impression relative...
by reddish22dond80 wrote:So, kolby and Patrick...at what point in reading my review did you NOT get that this was being presented entirely as one man's highly subjective opinion?!? And if you did get...
View ArticleReply: Tzolk'in: The Mayan Calendar:: Reviews:: Re: First impression relative...
by DaviddesJreddish22 wrote:My biggest point was that I felt your comments were very general, and not giving specific examplesIt seems quite specific to me.Everyone else reading it can decide whether...
View ArticleReply: Tzolk'in: The Mayan Calendar:: Reviews:: Re: First impression relative...
by reddish22 If BGG was just about comments people posted without any other differing opinions, it'd be a boring site indeed. I'm welcome to post anything I feel in response to his comments, and your...
View ArticleReply: Tzolk'in: The Mayan Calendar:: Reviews:: Re: First impression relative...
by dond80reddish22 wrote:My biggest point was that I felt your comments were very general, and not giving specific examples, which after one play I would expect. I'm not trying to argue with you......
View ArticleReply: Tzolk'in: The Mayan Calendar:: Reviews:: Re: First impression relative...
by reddish22 In my first post I asked the question so I could be sure, so I could be clear, then my second and subsequent posts have talked about what I felt was problematic, but this is my last post...
View ArticleReply: Tzolk'in: The Mayan Calendar:: Reviews:: Re: First impression relative...
by dond80reddish22 wrote:I do find it really funny that you and David keep giving me and others grief for posting negative comments on your review (mine specifically questioned a few things in the...
View ArticleReply: Tzolk'in: The Mayan Calendar:: Reviews:: Re: First impression relative...
by DaviddesJreddish22 wrote:I do find it really funny that you and David keep giving me and others grief for posting negative comments on your reviewYou started out by calling his criticisms of the...
View ArticleReply: Tzolk'in: The Mayan Calendar:: Reviews:: Re: First impression relative...
by jchobbstravvller wrote:My central point was that you're expressing this after ONE play. I'm sorry, but I'm baffled that you don't understand how that would rub people the wrong way. So, how many...
View ArticleReply: Tzolk'in: The Mayan Calendar:: Reviews:: Re: First impression relative...
by reddish22dond80 wrote:reddish22 wrote:I do find it really funny that you and David keep giving me and others grief for posting negative comments on your review (mine specifically questioned a few...
View ArticleReply: Tzolk'in: The Mayan Calendar:: Reviews:: Re: First impression relative...
by Smiesflott wrote:Like Graham Dean pointed out in his well written review here on the Geek, “The Technology and Temple tracks should be at the heart of the players strategic decisions, and the cogs...
View ArticleReply: Tzolk'in: The Mayan Calendar:: Reviews:: Re: First impression relative...
by clydeiiitravvller wrote:My central point was that you're expressing this after ONE play. I'm sorry, but I'm baffled that you don't understand how that would rub people the wrong way. I don't even...
View ArticleReply: Tzolk'in: The Mayan Calendar:: Reviews:: Re: First impression relative...
by sshawmd I played both The Great Zimbabwe and Tzolkin at Great Lakes Games this past weekend, and I couldn't agree more with the OP. I feared that the gears mechanism would be gimmicky, but its not -...
View ArticleReply: Tzolk'in: The Mayan Calendar:: Reviews:: Re: First impression relative...
by EeevilleBoots01 wrote:I agree with the idea that most card games can't really 'open out' for you until you've played them enough to see many, many different card interactions. But "really...
View ArticleReply: Tzolk'in: The Mayan Calendar:: Reviews:: Re: First impression relative...
by kretensshawmd wrote:But the game does NOT have a very large strategy space, and I think that it would wear out its welcome very quickly. I also have concerns that the multiple (4 or so) avenues of...
View ArticleReply: Tzolk'in: The Mayan Calendar:: Reviews:: Re: First impression relative...
by fisha Hmm, its interesting. In the first few games we have maximum 60-70 points, and everybody felt the same: the temple strategy is unbeatable. Next time I will try the buildings. :)
View ArticleReply: Tzolk'in: The Mayan Calendar:: Reviews:: Re: First impression relative...
by GeleteDaviddesJ wrote:travvller wrote:My central point was that you're expressing this after ONE play. I'm sorry, but I'm baffled that you don't understand how that would rub people the wrong...
View ArticleReply: Tzolk'in: The Mayan Calendar:: Reviews:: Re: First impression relative...
by pilgrim152 Thanks for taking the time to post a review.I happen to disagree with most of your conclusions, after only 2 plays (once before buying, once after), but I think the points you've brought...
View ArticleClik here to view.
Reply: Tzolk'in: The Mayan Calendar:: Reviews:: Re: First impression relative...
by Gelete Replayability issues must be pointed and detract from a game rating but they are only a remarkable drawback for me if they are really severe. I do love The Princes of Florence for instance, a...
View ArticleReply: Tzolk'in: The Mayan Calendar:: Reviews:: Re: First impression relative...
by flottpilgrim152 wrote:Thanks for taking the time to post a review.I happen to disagree with most of your conclusions, after only 2 plays (once before buying, once after), but I think the points...
View Article